top of page

A Dollar for Seventy Cents: Why Investment Companies Often Trade Below Their Value

21 minutes ago
3 min read

Something curious sometimes happens on the stock exchange. A company holds stakes in other businesses, the value of which can often be calculated precisely, because some of them are listed themselves. Yet that company's shares regularly trade well below the sum of what it owns. A discount of twenty to thirty percent is no exception among such investment companies. In effect, an investor can then buy a dollar of assets for seventy or eighty cents.


That looks like a free lunch, and in the financial world those are rare. To understand why this discount exists, and when it disappears, it is worth examining the causes one by one.


The cost of an extra layer


An investment company is an extra layer between the investor and the underlying businesses. That layer costs money: there is a head office, a board of directors, a supervisory board and sometimes interest on borrowings. In some countries the company also pays tax on its profits before they reach the shareholder. All those costs weigh on returns, and investors price them back into what they are willing to pay.


Uncertainty about value


Not all assets are equally easy to value. A stake in a listed company has a price every day, but a stake in an unlisted business has to be estimated. Investors do not always trust those estimates. The question of who ultimately benefits from the value also weighs heavily. If a company keeps reinvesting its money in new projects without ever paying anything out, the investor can see the value on paper but cannot get at it. That uncertainty is precisely what widens the discount.


Market sentiment plays a part as well. Investment companies are often followed by fewer analysts than large operating companies, and in turbulent periods it is precisely these less well-known shares that are sold first. The discount can therefore persist for years, or even widen.


When the discount disappears


The discount rarely disappears of its own accord. Something concrete is usually needed. The most important is that the company demonstrates that the value genuinely reaches its shareholders. That can be done by selling stakes and paying out the proceeds in cash, turning paper value into money in the investor's account. It can also be done by buying back its own shares at a price below the value of the assets. Every dollar spent that way effectively buys more than a dollar of underlying value for the remaining shareholders.


A third route is simplification. When a company reduces its portfolio to a few clear holdings, or lists a division separately, it becomes easier for investors to understand what they own. Transparency reduces uncertainty, and with it the discount.


Patience and discernment


Not every discount is a bargain. Sometimes it is justified, for instance because costs are high, the estimates too optimistic, or the board has little regard for shareholders' interests. The difference between an opportunity and a trap often lies in the behaviour of the board: is the value actively unlocked, or does it stay locked away? Anyone who answers that question carefully discovers that the gap between price and value on the stock exchange can sometimes persist for a long time, but seldom forever.



Disclaimer. This article is published by Lunar Asset Management N.V. for general informational and educational purposes only. It reflects the personal views of the author at the time of writing and does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation, an offer, or a solicitation to buy or sell any security or financial instrument. References to specific companies are illustrative and should not be interpreted as buy or sell recommendations. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Readers should consult a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decision based on their personal circumstances. Lunar Asset Management N.V. is supervised by the Centrale Bank van Curaçao en Sint Maarten (CBCS).

Comments


bottom of page